panthema / 2016
First slide of the talk

Presentation "Thrill: High-Performance Algorithmic Distributed Batch Data Processing with C++" at IEEE Big Data 2016

Posted on 2016-12-06 16:00 by Timo Bingmann at Permlink with 0 Comments. Tags: talk thrill

Today, I gave a presentation of our paper "Thrill: High-Performance Algorithmic Distributed Batch Data Processing with C++" at the IEEE International Conference on Big Data 2016 in Washington D.C., USA. An extended technical report of our paper is also available on this website or on arXiv.

The slides of the presentation at the IEEE conference are available here:
slides-Thrill-High-Performance-Algorithmic-Distributed-Batch-Data-Processing-with-CPP-TalkAsGiven.pdf slides-Thrill-High-Performance-Algorithmic-Distributed-Batch-Data-Processing-with-CPP-TalkAsGiven.pdf.

Below a longer version of the slides is available for download:
slides-Thrill-High-Performance-Algorithmic-Distributed-Batch-Data-Processing-with-CPP.pdf slides-Thrill-High-Performance-Algorithmic-Distributed-Batch-Data-Processing-with-CPP.pdf.
These slides contain additional figures which are useful to understand the DIA operations in Thrill, along with many extra design slides omitted from shorter talks.

Download slides-Thrill-High-Performance-Algorithmic-Distributed-Batch-Data-Processing-with-CPP.pdf

First slide of the talk

Presentation "STXXL and Thrill (Parallel Batch Processing)" at STXXL Workshop in DFG SPP 1736

Posted on 2016-09-21 20:00 by Timo Bingmann at Permlink with 0 Comments. Tags: talk thrill stxxl

Today, I gave a technical presentation comparing STXXL and Project Thrill at the STXXL Workshop organized within the DFG SPP 1736. The main topic of the workshop was to determine the future development course of STXXL, and the biggest question in this regard was how to bring more multi-core parallelization into STXXL. Thrill or an adaptation of its ideas may be the solution to this challenge: 2016-09-21 STXXL and Thrill Slides.pdf 2016-09-21 STXXL and Thrill Slides.pdf.

Download 2016-09-21 STXXL and Thrill Slides.pdf

A figure from the technical report

Thrill: High-Performance Algorithmic Distributed Batch Data Processing with C++

Posted on 2016-08-20 09:54 by Timo Bingmann at Permlink with 0 Comments. Tags: research c++ thrill

Our technical report on "Thrill: High-Performance Algorithmic Distributed Batch Data Processing with C++" is now available on arXiv as 1608.05634 or locally: 1608.05634v1.pdf 1608.05634v1.pdf with source 1608.05634v1.tar.gz 1608.05634v1.tar.gz (780 KiB).

This report is the first technical documentation about our new distributed computing prototype called Thrill. Thrill is written in modern C++14, and open source under the BSD-2 license. More information on Thrill is available from the project homepage.

Thrill's source is available from Github.

Download 1608.05634v1.pdf


We present the design and a first performance evaluation of Thrill -- a prototype of a general purpose big data processing framework with a convenient data-flow style programming interface. Thrill is somewhat similar to Apache Spark and Apache Flink with at least two main differences. First, Thrill is based on C++ which enables performance advantages due to direct native code compilation, a more cache-friendly memory layout, and explicit memory management. In particular, Thrill uses template meta-programming to compile chains of subsequent local operations into a single binary routine without intermediate buffering and with minimal indirections. Second, Thrill uses arrays rather than multisets as its primary data structure which enables additional operations like sorting, prefix sums, window scans, or combining corresponding fields of several arrays (zipping).

We compare Thrill with Apache Spark and Apache Flink using five kernels from the HiBench suite. Thrill is consistently faster and often several times faster than the other frameworks. At the same time, the source codes have a similar level of simplicity and abstraction.

Sketch of a edge-split-attach operation, which breaks a unique exchange from e.

On the Structure of the Graph of Unique Symmetric Base Exchanges of Bispanning Graphs - Diploma Thesis in Mathematics

Posted on 2016-01-14 18:30 by Timo Bingmann at Permlink with 0 Comments. Tags: maths university

After a long exhausting period with many interruptions my diploma thesis in mathematics "On the Structure of the Graph of Unique Symmetric Base Exchanges of Bispanning Graphs" is finalized and submitted. The full abstract of the thesis is shown below, and an additional German abstract is available further down the page.

The final version of the thesis is available here: thesis pdf Bingmann-On-the-Structure-of-the-Graph-of-Unique-Symmetric-Base-Exchanges-of-Bispanning-Graphs.pdf, and was also uploaded to as 1601.03526.

The underlying problem discussed in the thesis is best explained using a game on a bispanning graph. You can play the game with this Java Applet or using the Java WebStart Launcher (if the Applet does not work). You play Alice's role and want to flip the colors of all edges in the graph. Bob will try to prevent this from happening.

In addition to the thesis itself, the source code of the accompanying computer program is also available. It was used while preparing the thesis to calculate exchanges graphs and to test many hypothesis about bispanning graphs. The program can enumerate all bispanning graphs and their exchange graphs for small numbers of vertices. See the program page for downloadable lists and PDFs of all bispanning graphs for small numbers of vertices.


Bispanning graphs are undirected graphs with an edge set that can be decomposed into two disjoint spanning trees. The operation of symmetrically swapping two edges between the trees, such that the result is a different pair of disjoint spanning trees, is called an edge exchange or a symmetric base exchange. The graph of symmetric base exchanges of a bispanning graph contains a vertex for every valid pair of disjoint spanning trees, and edges between them to represent all possible edge exchanges. We are interested in a restriction of these graphs to only unique symmetric base exchanges, which are edge exchanges wherein selecting one edge leaves only one choice for selecting the other. In this thesis, we discuss the structure of the graph of unique symmetric edge exchanges, and the open question whether these are connected for all bispanning graphs.

This abstract problem can be nicely rephrased into a coloring game with two players: Alice and Bob are given a bispanning graph colored with two disjoint spanning trees, and Alice gets to flip the color of any edge. This creates a cycle in one color and a cut in the other, and Bob must then flip a different edge to repair the constraint that both colors represent disjoint spanning trees. Alice's objective is to invert the color of all edges in the graph, and Bob's to prevent this. We are interested in whether Alice can find a sequence of unique edge exchanges for any bispanning graph, since these leave Bob no choice in which edge to select, hence allowing Alice to win with certainty.

In this thesis, we first define and discuss the properties of bispanning graphs in depth. Intuitively, these are locally dense enough to allow the two disjoint spanning trees to reach all vertices, but sparse enough such that disjoint edge sets do not contain cycles. The whole class of bispanning graphs can be inductively constructed using only two operations, which makes the class tractable for inductive proofs.

We then describe in detail directed, undirected, and simplified versions of edge exchange graphs, first with unrestricted edge exchanges, and then with the restriction to unique symmetric base exchanges. These exchange graphs are related to a set of conjectures put forth by White in 1980 on base exchanges in matroids, and also to conjectures on cyclic base orderings of matroids. To date, these conjectures have not been proven in full generality, despite overwhelming computational evidence.

As steps towards showing the conjecture that the graph of unique symmetric base exchanges is connected for all bispanning graphs, we prove a composition method to construct the unique exchange graph of any bispanning graph from the exchange graphs of smaller bispanning graphs. Furthermore, using a computer program developed alongside this thesis, we are able to enumerate and make statements about all small bispanning graphs and their exchanges graphs.

Our composition method classifies bispanning graphs by whether they contain a non-trivial bispanning subgraph, and by vertex and edge connectivity. For bispanning graphs containing a non-trivial bispanning subgraph, we prove that the unique exchange graph is the Cartesian graph product of two smaller exchange graphs. For 2-vertex-connected bispanning graphs, we show that the bispanning graph is the 2-clique sum of two smaller bispanning graphs, and that the unique exchange graph can be built by joining their exchange graphs and forwarding edges at the join seam. And for all remaining bispanning graphs, we prove a composition method at a vertex of degree three, wherein the unique exchange graph is constructed from the exchange graphs of three reduced bispanning graphs.

We conclude this thesis with ideas and evidence for future approaches to proving the connectivity of the unique exchange graphs and show the most difficult bispanning graphs instances.

This blog entry continues on the next page ...

RSS 2.0 Weblog Feed Atom 1.0 Weblog Feed Valid XHTML 1.1 Valid CSS (2.1)
Copyright 2005-2016 Timo Bingmann - Impressum